All work

SEO case study

Case Study: Relaunching St. John Brewers for Search

How a 2022 site relaunch more than doubled a Caribbean brewery's estimated organic traffic.

Trunk Bay, St. John. Photo by Josh Duncan on Unsplash.

Results at a glanceAfter I relaunched the St. John Brewers website in 2022, estimated organic search traffic more than doubled, from about 829 to 1,800 monthly visits, and kept climbing into 2023. Google AI Mode, ChatGPT, and Claude all recommend it for searches that never mention its name, and Claude singles out The Tap Room in its general guide to things to do on St. John.
+117%Estimated organic traffic after the 2022 relaunch (829 to 1,800 monthly visits)
4.5★Google rating across 375 reviews on The Tap Room's profile, which I managed
224Keywords the site ranks for in U.S. search
26Semrush Authority Score, healthy for a regional brand

Traffic, keyword, and authority figures are Semrush estimates (U.S. database, October 2026).

The challenge

St. John Brewers had grown from a home-brew experiment into one of the Virgin Islands' best-known craft beer brands, and its audience was growing fast. The opportunity was to make the website as much of a destination as the brewery itself: a place where travelers planning a trip, and fans looking for a favorite beer, could find everything they wanted and a reason to come back.

What I did

In 2022, I relaunched stjohnbrewers.com around one idea: give people searching for the brewery, its beers, and the island a real reason to find it and stay.

The results

Estimated organic traffic rose from about 829 to 1,800 monthly visits after the relaunch, an increase of roughly 117%, and continued to climb into 2023. As of October 2026, the site ranks for 224 keywords.

The brewery also wins where travelers search without knowing its name. In October 2026, the St. John Brewers Tap Room was the #1 result in Google's local map listings for "best brewery on St. John USVI," with a 4.5-star rating from 375 reviews.

Context matters, and I want to be precise about it. These figures are third-party estimates, and much of the brewery's search traffic comes from people who already know the brand. The relaunch also coincided with tourism returning to the Virgin Islands after 2020. Traffic has softened since 2024, a pattern seen across many sites as Google answers more searches directly with AI Overviews.

AI visibility

Generative search is where GEO pays off. In October 2026, I asked Google's AI Mode for the "best brewery on St. John USVI," a search that doesn't include the brand name. Its answer:

ChatGPT gave the same verdict. Asked, "What's the best brewery on St. John USVI?" it chose the St. John Brewers Tap Room "pretty decisively" and featured the brewpub on a map with its rating.

ChatGPT answer naming St. John Brewers Tap Room as the best brewery on St. John
ChatGPT's answer, October 2026.

Claude, with web search turned on, recommended St. John Brewers as well, accurately naming The Tap Room at Mongoose Junction and the Mango Pale Ale as the flagship beer. One honest caveat: St. John Brewers is the island's only brewery, so the win here isn't beating competitors. It's that AI tools describe the brand accurately and favorably, link to its site, and retell its story.

The strongest signal came from a broader search. Asked for "things to do in St. John USVI," Claude built its answer around beaches, snorkeling, and hiking, and named exactly one bar or restaurant on the island: The Tap Room, home of St. John Brewers.

Claude answer recommending The Tap Room, home of St. John Brewers, for an evening in Cruz Bay
Claude's answer to "Things to do in St. John USVI," October 2026.

When AI tools summarize a brand in its own words and send readers to its site, the content is doing its job in the places people now search.

What's next

The next phase focuses on reaching people who don't know the brewery yet, and on being the source AI tools cite.